The expansion of Makhoul Dam, which commenced in January 2021, was planned to come to completion within five years and its finalisation would have reshaped the cultural landscape and geography of Sherqat, al Zab and surrounding areas. Makhoul Dam will affect both Kirkuk and Salahadeen provinces in Iraq.
The expansion of the dam, undertaken by the Ministry of Water Resources, is projected to affect directly over 183 archaeological sites, including Ashur and displace thousands of families. Some significant cultural sites will disappear altogether and parts of Ashur will also be flooded (Marchetti el al, 2019).
Whilst the expansion of the dam has started, there has been no real consultation with the people of the Makhoul Dam region, leaving many questions unanswered about the future of the area, its cultural sites and how the expansion will affect livelihoods, not least farming and the region’s tourism potential.
To date, there has been no social study of the impact of the dam, producing amongst communities in areas such as al Zab, Sherqat and many other places a sense of frustration about the future of the area.
Their voices, at this critical moment in time of change and possible transformation of the entire area, have neither been listened to nor documented. It has not been collected, organised and conveyed to decision-makers. This project addresses this deficiency and works with communities to document and convey in a professional manner those voices and concerns to key stakeholders, including the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, the Ministry of Migration and Displacement and the Ministry of Water Resources.
The project will act as an important and strategic intervention at a time when no one is actually working with or thinking about the concerns of local communities in the area.
This project explores the possible impact of the building of Makhoul Dam on communities in the provinces of Salahadeen and Kirkuk.
A communities - first approach has been employed to understand how Makhoul Dam will affect local society, including livelihoods, agriculture, infrastructure and heritage, amongst other key indicators. The project seeks to communicate those voices from villages in the Makhoul Dam Basin, which covers parts of Salahadeen and Kirkuk, to key stakeholders and decision-makers.
The project primarily covers the social and cultural impact of Makhoul Dam, looking also at livelihoods and economic factors pertinent to the areas under study. A multi-sectoral analysis is currently being conducted based on survey and interview data conducted on the ground in 40 villages.
The area was recently under DAESH occupation and the scars of wars and their legacies are raw and visible throughout the region. The region suffered from great levels of insecurity and displacment. Makhoul Dam may create significant levels of displacement in the near future.
Makhoul Dam will transform the economic infrastructure of Salahadeen and Kirkuk, both provinces that will in part be flooded. Our approach has been to assess the damage that the project will create on livelihoods and income generation in the basin and nearby areas as well as the economic opportunities it might produce.
No comprehensive study has been undertaken to explore the impact of Makhoul Dam on the region's heritage and archaeology. Home to major archaeological sites, including Ashur - a UNESCO World Heritage Site - the area has significant potential to be a major tourism hub in Iraq and beyond. Understanding the outcomes of Makhoul Dam on the areas archaeology is urgently requried.
As a farming area, which is watered by the River Tigris, the Makhoul Dam area is an environmentally diverse region of Iraq. The impact on the environment of the creation of a reservoir has not yet been studied or explored.
Until just recently, the Makhoul Dam region was affected by heavy conflict which destroyed a large section of its infrastructure and uprooted hundreds of thousands of people in the area. The impact of Makhoul Dam will similarly impact social life and the relationships people have forged with eachother.
Extended families, most living within the same or adjoining households characterise the region. The impact on families and households as a result of displacement and the instability that Makhoul Dam could create will have a lasting impact on the region and its people.
The project plans to complete four community roundtables to discuss the impact of Makhoul Dam and to listen and record those voices from potentially affected areas. These public forums are designed to act as a way for communities to channel their concerns, and frustrations, in a manner which could be recorded and amplified to key stakeholders. The first community event was organised in al Zab, in Kirkuk, on 9th September 2021 on the topic of archaeology and heritage in the region.
The project has completed mapping 39 of 40 villages in the Makhoul Dam basin region. To date, over 500 interviews have been conducted in the Makhoul Dam basin region. Both genders have been covered and different stratas of society in both Salahadeen and Kirkuk have been spoken with by researchers. Communities have been keen to participate in data collection and consultations with a view to conveying their voices to decison-makers.
The future security of the region being covered will depend on the capacity to generate sustainable livelihoods, especially as government incomes and farming cover the majority of gross domestic product. The project's researchers have covered this aspect of data collection to better understand the infratructure of the region, with a view to ensuring that livelihoods are adequately protected.
The project seeks to utilise Iraqi expertise in better understanding the impact of Makhoul Dam in the fields of archaeology, geography, income-generation, and other key sectors. On 9th September 2021, a one-day conference at the University of Tikrit was organised to this effect which saw the participation of academics from the affected areas. Further expert input is being carried out by a combination of different experts.
Key stakeholders concerning the Makhoul Dam, including central state agencies and Ministries, are currently being communicated with a view to compiling an assessment of the impact of Makhol Dam. Final outputs will be delivered to those key stakeholders with a view to ensuring adverse effects of the dam are kept to a minimum or avoided altogether. A final report on the social impact of Makhoul Dam will be released towards the end of the project phase, in late 2021.
Key sectors are explored including the impact of the dam on geography and environment in the region. To date, no such impact assessment has been prepared. Significantly, the Makhoul Dam basin region contains no less than 183 major archaeological sites, including Ashur, a UNESCO World Heritage Site. According to some assessments, parts of Ashur will be flooded once the dam is completed. The project attempts to raise awareness of the possible impact on heritage in the region as it possibly an important source of future income-generation through such things as tourism.
Seeking Adequate Compensation
Hamad Farhan from Sbeih Tahtani in Al-Zab in Kirkuk explains how Makhoul Dam may lead to communities being relocated and provided with unsuitable housing. He stressed that any future government compensation should take into account their current housing arrangements and needs.
Local economy and livelihoods
Oum Laith from Al-Zab in Kirkuk explains the adverse outcomes of Makhoul Dam on everyday life in the region and stressed those concerns to Liwan's Community Liaison Team. She goes on to stress the dam's possible impact on the local economy and farming communities.
In addition to the displacement of populations from the villages that the expansion is projected to result in, the dam will also detrimentally affect the possibility for the development of a sustainable, tourism-based economy, which will inevitably be based on the region’s unique Assyrian cultural heritage. Whilst some archaeological sites have been mapped, albeit through satellite imagery, no one has engaged with people and communities about the possible impact of the dam on the area’s archaeology and the possible impact it may have on its future. This is deeply worrying given that the Makhoul Dam basin areas potentially have a sustainable resource in the form of tourism in such sites as Ashur.
To date, there have been no interest or activity associated with the ways in which the expansion of the dam could affect people, communities and society over the next few years. As such, this project will, in this context, be the first such initiative to work with local communities to better understand their concerns and assist in ensuring their voices are listened to nationally, with relevant governmental institutions and internationally.
The Need for a Comprehensive Strategy
Emad from Al Houriya village in Salahaddin states that planning and a comprehensive strategy from the government regarding affected communities are required. He, however, does not oppose the construction of the dam.
Water Resource Challenges
Sheikhs and elderly people from Kirkuk and Salahaddin recall with nostalgia a time when the Tigris was a central trade route used for vessel navigation and now state that the river has dropped to record levels.
Absence of Planning
Dr Ahmed, a professor of geography and citizen of Al-Twiriya village in Tikrit, reiterates that local populations have not been approached by authorities regarding the future of their communities, creating an atmosphere of ambiguity and uncertainty regarding Makhoul Dam.
Heritage as an Essential Component of Identity
More than 183 archeological sites will be submerged because of Makhoul Dam including Ashur which is UNESCO World Heritage Site. Here we can listen to one of the citizens of the surrounding villages urging authorities to protect his community’s history and identity.